Is Fontsup.io legal? : typography

If it looks too good to be true, it probably is; this looks sketchy. Looks like they've also gone through fontsup.co and fontsup.com. If you use the Wayback Machine on the latter, you can see pages like this where people could upload fonts and you could download them for free.... fonts like "Gotham Rounded Bold", which is most certainly not offered for free legitimately.…